Skip to main content

Once an Alcoholic, Always an Alcoholic




If you know anything about the group Alcoholics Anonymous (AA) you probably know their famous slogan, “Once an alcoholic, always an alcoholic.”

People will stand up in their groups and introduce themselves: My name is _________, and I am an alcoholic. Some of the ones making that introduction have gone years without so much as a sip of beer, and yet they still refer to themselves as alcoholics.

While I do not want to be overly critical of a group that is committed to helping people overcome serious addictions, I do want to scrutinize their label of “alcoholic.”

My issue with that term is that it labels people in the present with a sometimes past diagnosis. Cancer survivors don’t say they have cancer, they say they beat cancer. In the same way, why continue to give credit to alcohol when you have beaten it’s seductive powers?

What do you expect an alcoholic to do? The answer is obvious: drink alcohol.

But what do you expect a former alcoholic to do? Abstain from alcohol.

So why call yourself an alcoholic when you are sober? I preached on this topic several years ago, and a man approached me later and told me I was wrong. He said he would always be an alcoholic, even though he had been sober for six months. I asked him why he would give credit to the devil instead of Jesus; through the power of God he broke the chains of bondage, but he still referred to himself by what he used to do. Today that man has returned to his old ways of daily drunkenness, and I always wonder if the fact that he refused to stop calling himself an alcoholic contributed to him actually becoming one.

The “always an alcoholic” line stands in direct contradiction to the Bible. Notice how Paul addressed those former alcoholics in 1 Corinthians 6:9-11:

“Or do you not know that the unrighteous will not inherit the kingdom of God? Do not be deceived: neither the sexually immoral, nor idolaters, nor adulterers, nor men who practice homosexuality, nor thieves, nor the greedy, nor drunkards, nor revilers, nor swindlers will inherit the kingdom of God. And such WERE some of you. But you were washed, you were sanctified, you were justified in the name of the Lord Jesus Christ and by the Spirit of our God.”

Paul addressed people who had formerly been drunkards. He did not say they would always be alcoholics because they had been washed, sanctified, and justified in the name of the Lord Jesus Christ!

If you have been delivered from the sin of alcoholism, or any other sin, then don’t continue to label yourself by your past sin. That gives Satan the bragging rights in your life. Instead, stand up and proudly testify about the Lord Jesus Christ and what He was able to do in your life.

Your story of deliverance can serve as a catalyst to encourage someone else to turn to God for help. But if you keep calling yourself an alcoholic, or any other type of sinner, than you are not offering hope and deliverance to those still in chains of sin.

Are you a former alcoholic? Then join Paul in “forgetting those things which are behind and pressing on towards what lies ahead (Philippians 3:13).”

Comments

Unknown said…
This comment has been removed by the author.
Unknown said…
You are arguing against a time tested, honored and very successful program. Members know they are just one drink away from alcohol destruction. Alcoholism is not a sin. It is a disease.

Rev. Dr. Wm. H. Phillips
Rev. Dr. Phillips, you are arguing against the Bible, which is a time tested, honored, very successful book. Unfortunately, many people today depart from the Word to embrace the word of man.

Bible-centered programs like Celebrate Recovery reject the "always an alcoholic" line and use only Scripture to help people beat their sin.

Yes, it is a sin. The Bible does not command us to repent of diseases; it says no drunkards will inherit the kingdom of God.

All humans are one sin away from spiraling out of control. But believers are no longer sinners, but saints.

Thank you for your comment. And as I said in the post, I am not trying to be overly critical because I acknowledge how much good has come from AA. But my point is that when psychology contradicts the Bible, as for me and my house, we will stick to the Bible.

Popular posts from this blog

To Save a Life

(Like my blog about the peace symbol, this blog was written as a default response to all the parents, students, and other people who are asking my opinion of To Save a Life.) By now you have probably heard of the movie To Save a Life, which opened nation-wide in theaters on January 22nd. The movie deals with so many issues that teens face today, like suicide, cutting, drinking, drugs, premarital sex, teen pregnancy, and abortion. At first glance this movie looks like an awesome resource that we should recommend for our teens, parents, youth pastors, and youth workers. But a closer look at the movie reveals a few disturbing things. For starters, according to pluggedin.com, there are 2 uses of the “A” word, 5 uses of hell (used as a curse word), and once the “D” word is used. There are other crude terms used to describe a girl, and crude terms for referring to sexual activity. There is also a bedroom scene that shows a girl removing a boy’s shirt, then afterwards the girl putting he...

Catechism #15

Q. By what sin did our first parents fall from their original condition? 
A. Our first parents’ sin was eating the forbidden fruit. The first sin we see in the Bible was in the eating of the forbidden fruit by Adam and Eve. But as we saw last week, there are sins of commission and omission. The eating of the fruit was an act of commission—a sin that was committed in the Garden of Eden. But before Eve ever took her first bite, a few sins of omission occurred that led up to the sin of commission. First, notice that it was Eve, not Adam, that did all the talking with the serpent in Genesis 3. Yet it was Adam, not Eve, who was created as the spiritual leader of the family. For whatever reason Adam abdicated his role as the spiritual leader and stood silently by as Eve ate the fruit. After Eve’s bite, she gave it to Adam, and he ate it too. Not only did Adam omit his role as leader, Eve omitted her trust in the goodness of God. Not only did she misquote God ...

All Things To All Men

One of our favorite verses to use in our evangelism methods is where Paul said that he “becomes all things to all men” so that he might “by all means save some (I Corinthians 9:22).” This is certainly a good idea if we keep it in its proper context and application. For example, I remember a time in high school where I knew a kid that loved skateboarding. Being the chicken that I am, I was never a skateboarder. All he would talk about was skating, and I knew none of his lingo. But to help develop a relationship with him (he was new to our church and didn’t know many people), I brushed up on my skating lingo so I could ask if he had done any sick ollies lately (impressed?). This would be like Paul saying “to the skateboarder, I became a skateboarder.” This is effective and necessary. But then there are the people that use this verse to justify doing sinful things in the name of evangelism. The first one that comes to mind is about drinking. Some people will go into the bars to evan...